Reasoning : Logical Reasoning & Analytical Ability

Q 1 / 325

UPSC CSE Prelims 2026

Consider the following statements:
  1. Every red is blue.
  2. Every blue is green.
  3. Every green is yellow.
Which of the following statements denoted by P, Q and R are correct?
  1. P. Every blue is yellow.
  2. Q. Every red is green.
  3. R. Every red is yellow.
Select the answer using the code given below.

EXPLANATION

The correct option is D - P, Q and R.

[as per provisional answerkey]

Why this is correct

This is a LOGICAL REASONING question based on Syllogisms. We can analyze the logical flow of the statements using the transitive property (If A is B, and B is C, then A is C):
1. Every red is blue (Red ⊂ Blue)
2. Every blue is green (Blue ⊂ Green)
3. Every green is yellow (Green ⊂ Yellow)

By combining these statements, we get a nested hierarchy: Red ⊂ Blue ⊂ Green ⊂ Yellow.

Now, let's evaluate the conclusions:
P. Every blue is yellow: Since Blue ⊂ Green and Green ⊂ Yellow, it logically follows that Blue ⊂ Yellow. This is correct.
Q. Every red is green: Since Red ⊂ Blue and Blue ⊂ Green, it logically follows that Red ⊂ Green. This is correct.
R. Every red is yellow: Since Red ⊂ Blue, Blue ⊂ Green, and Green ⊂ Yellow, the entire set of Red is contained within the set of Yellow. This is correct.

Why the other options are incorrect

  • Option (a) - P and Q only: This option is incorrect because it excludes statement R, which is a valid logical deduction from the given premises.
  • Option (b) - Q and R only: This option is incorrect because it excludes statement P, which is a direct consequence of the relationship between Blue, Green, and Yellow.
  • Option (c) - P and R only: This option is incorrect because it excludes statement Q, which is a valid deduction based on the relationship between Red, Blue, and Green.

Key Concept

The transitive property of categorical syllogisms, where if set A is a subset of B and B is a subset of C, then A is necessarily a subset of C.