Reasoning : General Mental Ability

Q 20 / 45

UPSC CSE Prelims 2018

A group of 19 boys decided to play hockey. Out of these boys, 11 are wearing hockey shirts and 14 are wearing hockey pants. There are no boys without shirts and pants. What is the number of boys wearing full uniform?

EXPLANATION

Correct Option (3)

The problem can be solved using principles of set theory. Let S represent the set of boys wearing hockey shirts and P represent the set of boys wearing hockey pants.

  • Total number of boys (N) = 19
  • Number of boys wearing shirts (|S|) = 11
  • Number of boys wearing pants (|P|) = 14

The statement "There are no boys without shirts and pants" implies that every boy is wearing at least a shirt or pants (or both). Therefore, the total number of boys is equal to the union of boys wearing shirts and boys wearing pants (|S ∪ P| = N).

The number of boys wearing full uniform corresponds to the intersection of boys wearing shirts and boys wearing pants (|S ∩ P|).

Using the Principle of Inclusion-Exclusion:

|S ∪ P| = |S| + |P| - |S ∩ P|

Substituting the given values:

19 = 11 + 14 - |S ∩ P|

19 = 25 - |S ∩ P|

|S ∩ P| = 25 - 19

|S ∩ P| = 6

Alternatively, consider the boys not wearing pants:

  • Number of boys not wearing pants = Total boys - Number of boys wearing pants = 19 - 14 = 5.

Since no boy is without shirts and pants, these 5 boys must be wearing only shirts.

  • Total number of boys wearing shirts = 11.
  • Number of boys wearing only shirts = 5.

Therefore, the number of boys wearing both shirts and pants (full uniform) is:

Number of boys in full uniform = (Total boys wearing shirts) - (Boys wearing only shirts)

Number of boys in full uniform = 11 - 5 = 6.

Incorrect Options:

Options 1 (3), 2 (5), and 4 (8) are incorrect because they do not satisfy the conditions derived from the problem statement. Any value other than 6 for the number of boys wearing full uniform would lead to a contradiction when applying the Principle of Inclusion-Exclusion or the alternative method. For example, if 5 boys were in full uniform, the total number of boys would be (11 - 5) + (14 - 5) + 5 = 6 (only shirts) + 9 (only pants) + 5 (both) = 20, which contradicts the given total of 19 boys.